Wednesday, September 16, 2009

Baucus Health Care Plan (September 17, 2009)

This is such a touchy issue that has been evident in our society for centuries now and even current times. It is the issue of race. It is now plastered all over the media today. Mainly because it is concerning our leader of this country. You can't look past this issue when someone yells, "You lie!" at the the person who is holding the highest position in the country. However, according to the huffingtonpost.com, Obama himself is stating that he doesn't believe that he was being criticized because of his race. So I will digress from this issue and concentrate on another important issue going on in this country which is health care and today was a very important day. I am going to focus my critique on Max Baucus, who released his health care bill and is getting fire from both sides. 

The New York Times released a story on this subject called "Baucus Offers Health Plan, But Lacks GOP Support." The New York Times seems to have spent a lot of time on this story. I think that the writer of this story has a neutral view and an independence from faction. It is very informative and shows views from both angles

This story defines pretty much all the basic questions that a journalist answers when writing a piece. What the Barcus plan is, who it will cover, and why the bill will be essential. Also, it defines the stipulations and limits of the plan. One thing that The New York Times highlights is stated by Baucus is, "no Republican has offered his or her support at the moment." However, this story ends with hope and somewhat of a light on this health care reform. A total and opposite ending to the story from The Washington Times, which basically shows doom to the bill.

The Washington Times wrote "Baucus Health Plan Attracts no GOP Backers" This story also answers many of the basic questions. However, it is evident that there was not as much time spent in this story as The New York Times did. I say this because the New York Times is so informative in every aspect. in describing the parts of the bill, I feel so much more informed from reading the NY Times as opposed to the Washington Times. However, in the Washington Times, the information concerning the plan is laid out earlier in the story within the first couple of paragraphs. The New York Times stretched the information all through the story. The Washington Times writes of this group called the "Gang of SIx". This is not even mentioned in the New York Times story.

I turned onto Fox News and switched it on between CNN. CNN has this topic of Baucus's health care plan shown first, while Fox has another story playing first then shows this story second. The basic outline of Fox news showed the outline of the plan. It also stated that the plan will be neutral. Tells of both objections by the Democrats and Republicans. i am actually shocked by how many Democrats are against this plan now. However, Fox is stating that the Republicans are saying that there could still be a possibility that they could agree on some compromise

With CNN I felt more coverage on this issue. Mainly leaning toward the left. However, CNN stated more on the issue of the cuts the government programs, the added taxes and fees, and also shows how they will finance this program. What was also stated was how discrimination will be banned and that all Americans will be required to have health care by 2010.

These four news sources are what I looked into today. I will check on MSNBC and the internet sources over the weekend and point out more on these sources within the next few days. While this what I would like to call "needless" debate and sensationalistic journalism over race and the presidency keeps presiding, hopefully eyes will be opened and focus on the more important issue at hand right now.



No comments:

Post a Comment