The American Health Insurance Plan (AHIP) released a report over the weekend stating that the Senate Finance Committee (SFC) legislation would cost health care costs to go up faster than under the current system.
Now this report was dropped right before the important vote on Tuesday that would decide whether they are overhauling the current health care system or not.
Both The Huffington Post and Politico feel two different opinions about this bill.
The Huffington Post titles their article: "AHIP Report Makes Strongest Case in Weeks for Public Opinion". Politico titles theirs with: "AHIP Report to Take Whack at SFC Bill."
In reading an article from Politico, they state that the AHIP who has "spoken publicly in favor of overhauling the health care system, has also worked behind the scenes to kill aspects of the president's plan, including attempts to create a government competitor to private plans." Politico also provides a link to the whole report. The report is missing from The Huffington Post. The whole report basically summarizes to the rising costs which in turn is the "whack" that the titles means.
The AHIP seems a bit questionable to me, and untrustable.
The Huffington Post states that under the SFC, family premiums would rise more than $4,000. This statement is missing from Politico. They do write that costs would rise, but they do not state by how much.
The Huffington Post's story was written more about the viewpoint of Democratic Representative, Anthony Weiner, who appeared on MSNBC and was asked about the health care front."I think in a strange way and obviously they didn't mean this, the health insurance lobby fired the most important salvo in weeks for the option," said Weiner. "Because they have said clear as day... they'll raise rates 111%." This in my opinion shows a dependence on faction with an extreme left side. With Politico's article, I feel as it may be even more extremely left. The article ends with a paragraph stated by the SFC spokesman, Scott Mulhauser who states that the report is "pitching some seriously flawed analysis". He is also stated through out the article with statements like, "This report is untrue, disingenous, and bought and paid for by the same health insurance companies that have been gouging too many consumers for too long as they stand in the way of reform yet again."
Both of these articles bring voice to the voiceless. I think this because many in favor of the public option have people who are speaking out for them and nailing the ones who are misleading the public. This is what journalism should be and continue to become again.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Your comments are well-thought out, but I'd still like for you to better address the issues the project asks of you:
ReplyDelete1) Evidence of story's impact on citizens
2) Evidence of monitoring power and offering voice to the voiceless
3) What's missing in the story or article?
4) How does the information differ between various media?
5) Include how much time/space is devoted to story
6) Evidence of independence from factions (or dependence on factions)
7) Can you find the truth of the story? What is it?
Also, you need to raise the level of posts. The syllabus states:
You should have a minimum of 12 weeks covered in you online blog. A week’s coverage is equal to a minimum of 4 entries (four separate days) of at least 300 words. Remember, these are the minimum requirements—what you need to get at least a “C” on the assignment.
You should have 16-20 posts at this point.
Midterm: 60