Thursday, November 12, 2009

President Obama Backs Non-Censorship

Upon President Obama's travel to Asia, he spoke at a forum of 400 government selected students in Beijing. He spoke that he believes that the freedom of expression should not be censored in any country. This sparked quite a controversy in the Chinese government.

I have read and critiqued two stories from The Washington Post and the UK's The Telegraph.

This story had evidence of impact on citizens, however, the citizens in this story are more aimed at Chinese nationals.

The voiceless in this story are the Chinese citizens. And the Washington Post does a better job in getting quotes from the Chinese students to get their opinion. there is no quotes from the voiceless in the Telegraph.

There is evidence of monitoring of power in each. From the Telegraph: "The leaders will have tears in their eyes! They filled the audience with ultra-nationalists, but they couldn't prevent a surprise attack from the US embassy," remarked one anonymous commenter on a Chinese internet forum.
From The Washington Post: It states how many internet sites in China wrote stories about Obama's speech, but an hour later were deleted by the government "watchdogs" and Obama's live broadcast was switched over to many children's programs and deleted web casts after Obama was asked about internet freedom.

The Washington Post's story seems to have more time devoted to the issue than the Telegraph. However, it does make more sense because the Post is a US media and should inform a lot better.

The differences I saw in the two stories is that The Washington Post does in fact get both sides and opinions from each, it is more informative, seems more dependent on factions because there is much talk and praise on the president from quotes and personal opinion. In fact there is a whole page devoted to the personal issues of the president. The Telegraph shows me more independence from factions and less opinionated. I think the Telegraph is missing quotes and voice from the people of China.

I got the truth from both stories. Each inform how the government is censoring the freedoms of the Chinese to be able to speak out on their issues. Obama is just trying to speak out for the citizens of China.

No comments:

Post a Comment